Charitable Giving: Donor-Advised Funds vs. Private Foundations

Many financial planners suggest charitable giving tools to their philanthropic clients as a part of their wealth management strategy. Often, the go-to recommendation for wealthy clients is a Donor-Advised Fund (DAF) because of their simplicity, quick setup, and low maintenance. However, there are scenarios where a private foundation could be more suitable.

Let’s examine and compare both vehicles to clarify and possible confusion

What is a Private Foundation

A private foundation is a type of charitable organization that is usually funded by a single individual, family, or corporation. Unlike public charities, which rely on public fundraising to support their activities, private foundations typically have a single major source of funding, usually in the form of an endowment, and they use the income generated by that endowment to make grants to other charitable organizations or, in some cases, directly fund their charitable activities. Here are some key points about private foundations:

Control and Autonomy: Since they're often funded by an individual or a family, private foundations usually provide the donors or their appointees with more control over their assets and grantmaking decisions compared to public charities.

Grantmaking: One of the primary activities of many private foundations is making grants to other nonprofit organizations. Some foundations have specific areas of focus, such as education, health, or the environment.

Minimum Annual Distribution: In the U.S., private foundations are required by the Internal Revenue Service (IRS) to distribute at least 5% of their assets for charitable purposes each year.

Regulations and Taxation: Private foundations in the U.S. are subject to different regulatory and tax rules than public charities. For instance, they're subject to stricter regulations regarding their investments and are also required to pay an excise tax on their net investment income.

Transparency: Although private foundations have a significant degree of autonomy, they are still required to file annual returns with the IRS, which are public records. This ensures a level of transparency regarding their financial activities and grantmaking.

Varieties: There are different types of private foundations, including operating foundations (which use their resources to run their charitable programs) and non-operating or grantmaking foundations (which distribute funds to other charitable entities).

In summary, a private foundation is a charitable organization that is primarily funded by an individual, family, or corporation and operates with a significant degree of control by its donors or appointed trustees. While they are tasked with serving the public good, they have specific operational, regulatory, and tax characteristics that distinguish them from public charities.

Private Foundations Pros:

Control and Autonomy: Foundations often allow for greater control over investments and grantmaking decisions. The donor or their appointees can actively manage the foundation.

Legacy Building: They can be named for a family or individual, allowing for long-term legacy building and family involvement.

Varied Grantmaking: Foundations can make grants to a broader range of organizations, including non-traditional charitable endeavors.

Direct Charitable Activities: Can operate their own programs or projects in line with their mission.

Operational Flexibility: Can hire staff, including family members, pay them a reasonable salary, and even have office space.

Private FoundationsCons:

Higher Operating Costs: Typically, there are more administrative responsibilities, which can translate to higher costs.

Regulation: Subject to stricter regulations by the IRS, including mandatory annual distribution requirements (usually 5% of assets).

Excise Tax: Subject to excise tax on net investment income.

Public Disclosure: Required to file detailed annual returns (Form 990-PF) which are publicly available, disclosing grants, salaries, and investments.

What is a Donor Advised Fund:

A Donor-Advised Fund (DAF) is a philanthropic giving vehicle administered by a public charity. It allows donors to make a charitable contribution, receive an immediate tax deduction, and then recommend grants from the fund over time. Here are some key points about DAFs:

Establishment: Donors can establish a DAF by making an irrevocable donation to a public charity that sponsors a DAF program. This can include community foundations, financial institutions, or other nonprofit entities that offer DAF services.

Tax Benefits: Contributions to a DAF are typically tax-deductible in the year they are made. The assets in the DAF also grow tax-free.

Grant Recommendations: While donors can advise or recommend how the assets of the DAF are distributed to charities, the sponsoring organization has the final authority over the distribution. In practice, though, most donor recommendations are followed.

Asset Types: DAFs can be funded with a variety of assets, including cash, stocks, bonds, and sometimes non-liquid assets like real estate or private business interests.

Flexibility: Donors can make recommendations for grants at their own pace. There's no mandatory distribution requirement for DAFs, unlike private foundations.

Low Maintenance: DAFs are administered by the sponsoring organization, so donors don't need to manage administrative details, legal requirements, or grant paperwork, making DAFs a simpler option compared to establishing a private foundation.

Privacy: Grants from a DAF can be made anonymously, allowing donors to support causes without public recognition if they choose.

Legacy Planning: Many DAFs allow for succession planning, enabling donors to pass on advisory privileges to the next generation.

In summary, a Donor-Advised Fund provides individuals, families, and businesses with a flexible and efficient way to support their favorite charities while optimizing their tax benefits. It offers the advantages of ease of administration, flexibility in grant-making, and immediate tax benefits.

Donor-Advised Funds (DAFs) Pros:

Simplicity: Easier to set up and manage than private foundations. The sponsoring organization handles administrative tasks.

Tax Advantages: Immediate tax deduction upon contribution. Also, assets grow tax-free.

Low Costs: Typically, there are lower fees and no startup costs.

Anonymity: Donors can make grants anonymously.

Flexibility: Donors can contribute assets and recommend grants at their own pace.

Cons:

Limited Control: Once assets are contributed, the DAF's sponsoring organization has legal control. While donor grant recommendations are typically honored, they're not binding.

Limitations on Grantmaking: Some DAFs may have restrictions on international giving or might limit grants to IRS-recognized public charities.

No Direct Charitable Activities: DAFs cannot run their own charitable programs or projects.

Less Visibility: DAFs offer less visibility and legacy-building potential than a named private foundation.

Which One to Choose?

Private Foundations might be ideal for those wanting a high degree of control, the ability to directly run charitable activities, or those looking to create a lasting family legacy.

Donor-Advised Funds are suitable for donors seeking simplicity, immediate tax benefits, and fewer administrative responsibilities, especially if they're primarily interested in grantmaking without the overhead of running a separate entity.

It's essential to consult with financial and legal advisors to determine the best fit based on individual or family goals, assets, and philanthropic vision.

Have questions, schedule your no-obligation consultation here.

Disclaimer:

Information provided is for informational purposes only, and does not constitute an offer or solicitation to sell, a solicitation of an offer to buy, any security or any other product or service. Accordingly, this document does not constitute investment advice or counsel or solicitation for investment in any security. The information in this material is not intended as tax or legal advice. Please consult legal or tax professionals for specific information regarding your individual situation.